Quite a while ago ago I talked to a company which was looking to kick off a bigger software project. They never went ahead with it and it was just another deal which did not bear fruit. Nothing unusual about it.
What makes it newsworthy though is that the CEO of the company reached out a few months ago and asked if we were to able to pick up the maintenance and service for the software they had developed.
Obviously a pretty easy thing to do. We priced it out, arranged for the delivery of the software (source code) and got to work. As is customary in those situations we had a few developers read through the code with the goal to familiarize ourselves with the code and the functionality.
As part of the code review we found some developer comments (once again...nothing unusual). What made it a bit unusual was that burred in the code were clear references as to which company had actually written the code.
This is where things got interesting. Below is a quasi recap of the the conversation I had with the CEO, our client.
Steve: So....when XYZ (company name embedded in the code) developed the API they...
CEO Interrupts me: Who is XYZ ?
Steve: The guys who developed the code
CEO: No..they aren't
Steve....(pause...does not say anything)
CEO: What makes you say that ?
Steve: Well..there are clear references in the code that they are the author of the software you delivered
CEO: What ?...I don't understand...we had it written by XXX
The CEO (our client) then took it upon himself to get to the bottom of the issue. Did not take him to long to find out as to what had happened.
The company which he had contracted with to develop the software had outsourced the entire development to a provider in India.
The CEO was rather flabbergasted that this was possible. He had paid premium pricing (his words) assuming that the product was going to be developed onshore in the US. Doing the math by using our rates he figured he had spent about 250k more than what he should have paid.
Obviously 250k can be a lot or very little money for a corporation. In this case the company is privately owned and the CEO happens to be the majority shareholder. Company is doing well...so money was (or is) not the issue.
The issue for the CEO was simply that he felt he had been taken advantage off...led to believe that it was an onshore development when in reality all of the work (or vast majority) was done offshore.
And this brings us to the dirty truth every CEO should know.
A lot of software development billed at domestic developer pricing is parsed out to providers offshore.
Decision makers should be aware that not in every case what is sold as a domestic development is actually developed domestically.
There is obviously a certain added comfort level for a US company to deal with a US based software development company. The CEO/Decision Maker might feel more comfortable...but the truth of the matter is that the company might not be exactly getting what it has paid for.
A collection of comments,newsworthy articles and posts dealing with outsourcing and BPO services by Steve Benger
- Home
- Which Are Better..Indian or Philippines Call Centers ?
- Why Your Business Will Benefit From Outsourcing
- Is Your Web Presence Up To Par ?
- How IBM's Watson Might Kill The Call Center Industry
- How To Test Your Outsourced Software Development
- Guerrilla CEO…How To Adapt When Needed
- Think Your Don't Need a Business Mobile App? Think Again!
How The Business Of Law Will Outsource To An Artificial Intelligence Unit...Think Watson
It has been a long time in the making but it finally happened. A major US law firm (Bakeler & Hosteler, about 1000 attorneys) just signed up as the first customer for IBM's "artificial intelligence attorney". The AI attorney is part of Watson...IBM's rather famous artificial intelligence engine.
A lot of people are wondering what the long term consequences society will suffer once knowledge can be disseminated via AI units in a coherent and meaningful way.
The business of law is one industry which might change more than any other business because of it. By outsourcing the legal research supporting or disproving a legal theory army's of lawyers might become irrelevant.
In the future all what it takes to build a case (or retort) is a well written query to retrieve the information in a contextual relevant matter which might be assembled by an army of lawyer otherwise.
The implications over the long run are staggering. Theoretically a 3 lawyer law firm will be able to muster the same quality of legal work as a 100 attorney firm.
Of course...legal research is just the first step. Once the AI unit has been on the job for a certain period it should be able to output the requested information in a style which can be cut and paste into a legal motion. Rather than the attorney drafting the motion (at $ 500 or more the hour) it will be a cut and paste job..potentially done by a paralegal.
Of course...we are a bit away from that but anyone who believes it will be decades rather than a few short years might be in for a rude awakening.
The business of law has been fighting a need to reduce costs and an unwillingness by clients to pay more ever since the 2008 recession.
An outsourcing solution which produces equal or better quality at a greatly reduced cost has been the impetus of countless other industries to set up business processes in India or the Philippines. (or anywhere else for that matter).
You can bet that there will be countless other law firms who will follow the first one. If history is any indications once an industry starts outsourcing the process will not stop.
At the end of the day outsourcing legal work to an AI engine might make the business of law more democratic and cheaper for the users ...and this would be good news for everyone apart from the individual attorney who might not be able to bill the same amount of hours.
A lot of people are wondering what the long term consequences society will suffer once knowledge can be disseminated via AI units in a coherent and meaningful way.
The business of law is one industry which might change more than any other business because of it. By outsourcing the legal research supporting or disproving a legal theory army's of lawyers might become irrelevant.
In the future all what it takes to build a case (or retort) is a well written query to retrieve the information in a contextual relevant matter which might be assembled by an army of lawyer otherwise.
The implications over the long run are staggering. Theoretically a 3 lawyer law firm will be able to muster the same quality of legal work as a 100 attorney firm.
Of course...legal research is just the first step. Once the AI unit has been on the job for a certain period it should be able to output the requested information in a style which can be cut and paste into a legal motion. Rather than the attorney drafting the motion (at $ 500 or more the hour) it will be a cut and paste job..potentially done by a paralegal.
Of course...we are a bit away from that but anyone who believes it will be decades rather than a few short years might be in for a rude awakening.
The business of law has been fighting a need to reduce costs and an unwillingness by clients to pay more ever since the 2008 recession.
An outsourcing solution which produces equal or better quality at a greatly reduced cost has been the impetus of countless other industries to set up business processes in India or the Philippines. (or anywhere else for that matter).
You can bet that there will be countless other law firms who will follow the first one. If history is any indications once an industry starts outsourcing the process will not stop.
At the end of the day outsourcing legal work to an AI engine might make the business of law more democratic and cheaper for the users ...and this would be good news for everyone apart from the individual attorney who might not be able to bill the same amount of hours.
India Is Still The 800 Pound Gorilla In IT Outsourcing...
India might have lost its leadership in call centers to the Philippines...but it certainly does not show any signs of slowing down when it comes to ITO (IT Outsourcing).
There is certainly strength in raw numbers. With a population of almost a Billion people India is basically the only place in the world where a major company can set up with the goal to hire a 1000 software engineers and not running into problems as to pricing and general availability of talent.
The building of technology centers where a few thousand engineers can be supervised under one roof has always been the one advantage none of India' competitors in the global outsourcing world can match.
India's National Association of Software and Service Companies (Nasscom) just announced that the sector increased employment by about 230,000 in 2015. Total employment for the sector now stands at about 35 Million.
By their own estimate the Indian BPM sector (Business Process Management) has now captured approximately 56 % of the total global market for IT related outsourcing services.
These are huge numbers. If you consider that the entire population of the Philippines is only about 98 million and India employs just in ITO 35 Million...it really shows that there is strength in raw numbers.
Of course, only few companies really have a need to hire hundred's of developers and for most companies there are other places in the world to get their ITO done as good or perhaps even better than what India has to offer.
At the end of the day it only matters what your own outsourcing team is capable off...as such there is really no strategic advantage outside of sheer numbers India can offer.
Never the less though...the numbers are impressive.
India's Nasscom Releases 2015 Revenue And Market Share Numbers
There is certainly strength in raw numbers. With a population of almost a Billion people India is basically the only place in the world where a major company can set up with the goal to hire a 1000 software engineers and not running into problems as to pricing and general availability of talent.
The building of technology centers where a few thousand engineers can be supervised under one roof has always been the one advantage none of India' competitors in the global outsourcing world can match.
India's National Association of Software and Service Companies (Nasscom) just announced that the sector increased employment by about 230,000 in 2015. Total employment for the sector now stands at about 35 Million.
By their own estimate the Indian BPM sector (Business Process Management) has now captured approximately 56 % of the total global market for IT related outsourcing services.
These are huge numbers. If you consider that the entire population of the Philippines is only about 98 million and India employs just in ITO 35 Million...it really shows that there is strength in raw numbers.
Of course, only few companies really have a need to hire hundred's of developers and for most companies there are other places in the world to get their ITO done as good or perhaps even better than what India has to offer.
At the end of the day it only matters what your own outsourcing team is capable off...as such there is really no strategic advantage outside of sheer numbers India can offer.
Never the less though...the numbers are impressive.
India's Nasscom Releases 2015 Revenue And Market Share Numbers
Strange News Part 2 - More About The Indian Diesel Saga - Indian BPO Industry Save For Now
I wrote about it a few days ago...and the apparent resolution is just to good not to come back to it. For your reference see the original post here: Strange News On Indian Diesel Cabs
Apparently the Supreme Court has decided to leave the diesel cabs on the road for now, thus providing a reprieve to the local BPO industry.
India is well known for its bureaucracy...and reading the article shown below makes clear why. There are 2 organizations able to issue taxi permits. Both organizations have different permit standards and are geared towards different sides of the market. One version of the cabs is for tourists only.
It will be interesting how it will resolve itself over time but at least for the moment the status quo has been maintained and the Indian BPO employee can be ferried to and back from work.
Indian Diesel Cab Standoff Resolved
Apparently the Supreme Court has decided to leave the diesel cabs on the road for now, thus providing a reprieve to the local BPO industry.
India is well known for its bureaucracy...and reading the article shown below makes clear why. There are 2 organizations able to issue taxi permits. Both organizations have different permit standards and are geared towards different sides of the market. One version of the cabs is for tourists only.
It will be interesting how it will resolve itself over time but at least for the moment the status quo has been maintained and the Indian BPO employee can be ferried to and back from work.
Indian Diesel Cab Standoff Resolved
Is Your Outsourcing Operation Bloated ?..Probably Yes...
Most companies enter into outsourcing relationships on a FTE basis. (Full Time Equivalent). The engagements are not project based but rather utilize a Lease To Hire model. (LTH). The Lease to Hire model basically means that the company buys the use of personnel on a Full Time Basis.
Once the outsourcing team is established and commences its work the most relevant Key Performance Indicator being watched is utilization of the employee. There are various tools to measure the KPI's as it relates to the utilization rate of the employee. For call centers and customer service operations it is rather simple (time on phone. time on call), for software development there are auditing tools available to make sure that the developers do not "slouch".
However, one particular problem with outsourcing is that the outsourced operation is really good at the troubleshoot...but perhaps not so good at looking at the root of the problem as to why the troubleshoot happened in the first place.
Consequently faulty software or procedures tend to stay around much longer than they should. Everyone is content with resolving the trouble tickets but no one is looking how to change procedures or applications so that the trouble ticket does not happen anymore.
Of course..the very same operational characteristic can be found in a domestic business environment. What makes it more of an issue in an outsourced offshore environment is that it takes key management much longer to realize what is going on.
And this brings us to the "Bloat" your outsourcing operation might have accumulated. If you do not periodically (or better yet...have a constant quality improvement program) review the source of trouble tickets and scan for improvement to be made...you might have built up your outsourced team well above your actual operational needs if those issues were fixed.
Implementing a procedures which reviews the source of a trouble ticket and/or increase operational efficiency will result in less contacts needs by your customers. Reducing the point of contacts will then lead to reduced need of FTE employees...thus reducing the manpower bloat you might be experiencing.
Once the outsourcing team is established and commences its work the most relevant Key Performance Indicator being watched is utilization of the employee. There are various tools to measure the KPI's as it relates to the utilization rate of the employee. For call centers and customer service operations it is rather simple (time on phone. time on call), for software development there are auditing tools available to make sure that the developers do not "slouch".
However, one particular problem with outsourcing is that the outsourced operation is really good at the troubleshoot...but perhaps not so good at looking at the root of the problem as to why the troubleshoot happened in the first place.
Consequently faulty software or procedures tend to stay around much longer than they should. Everyone is content with resolving the trouble tickets but no one is looking how to change procedures or applications so that the trouble ticket does not happen anymore.
Of course..the very same operational characteristic can be found in a domestic business environment. What makes it more of an issue in an outsourced offshore environment is that it takes key management much longer to realize what is going on.
And this brings us to the "Bloat" your outsourcing operation might have accumulated. If you do not periodically (or better yet...have a constant quality improvement program) review the source of trouble tickets and scan for improvement to be made...you might have built up your outsourced team well above your actual operational needs if those issues were fixed.
Implementing a procedures which reviews the source of a trouble ticket and/or increase operational efficiency will result in less contacts needs by your customers. Reducing the point of contacts will then lead to reduced need of FTE employees...thus reducing the manpower bloat you might be experiencing.
4 Key Points Which Will Make It Easy To Keep Your Outsourced Software Development On Track
The successful management of an outsourcing relationship often times seems like a daunting task to new users of offshore services. From my perspective it is actually not that complicated and there are quite a few things the user can do to succeed.
The points I am mentioning below are meant to be general guidelines and are by no means an all encompassing approach to manage your outsourcing relationship.
Below are some of my personal favorites which should provide the newcomer to outsourcing some good pointers. It is a general list meant to be for the newcomer to outsourcing.
#1
When In Doubt Repeat Yourself, Make Yourself Clear and Explain, Explain, Explain!
Might seem obvious but it pays to really explain what you want to get done. Be as descriptive as possible and try to have your vision bolstered by diagrams, flow charts and organization charts where and when needed. I also urge you to use collaborative tools designed for the management of software development.
#2
Treat Your Outsourcing Team As An Employee Or Partner...Not A Vendor
Might seem obvious but for some people it is not as easy. Treat your offshore staff as employees or partners in your venture. Stay in constant communication, (at least once a day), ask what is new and ask for progress reports. Also..make it a point o use video conferencing to have face to face time with the main people in your team (Project Manager or Lead Developer)....over time this will greatly reduce communication barriers.
#3
Have clear goals and milestones goals
Don't fall into the trap of continuing development thinking that the final product will be just fine. Make it a point to have clear milestones and performance goals established. Track the progress the team is reporting in the daily reports versus the timeline in the milestones. (sprints). If there are delays get to the bottom of it. Making your team feel accountable will go a long way to ensure that you finish on time and budget.
#4
Be Realistic in your expectations
There is nothing worse in an outsourcing relationship than unrealistic expectations. In particular when the relationship is new it is important to set goals which can be met (assuming that the team does its job). Going back to # 2; unrealistic expectations can be very demotivating to you and your team. You owe it to yourself and your new team to offer a fair chance to succeed. Unrealistic expectations are an easy way to make sure that you feel your outsourcing venture it is a failure.
#5
Pick a good outsourcing partner
I put this purposely last. The fact of the matter is that all of the above is irrelevant if you happen to end up with a body shop which is simply incapable working in a cooperative environment. These vendors will have the lowest price (which makes them attractive) but you will end up in a situation where quality of the work and a strong client orientated collaborative approach is not a goal.
I would like to mention that a good BPO partner will have a structure in place which takes some of the responsibility mentioned in points 1, 2 and 3 away from you and automates the suggested processes. This will greatly help the process.
The points I am mentioning below are meant to be general guidelines and are by no means an all encompassing approach to manage your outsourcing relationship.
Below are some of my personal favorites which should provide the newcomer to outsourcing some good pointers. It is a general list meant to be for the newcomer to outsourcing.
#1
When In Doubt Repeat Yourself, Make Yourself Clear and Explain, Explain, Explain!
Might seem obvious but it pays to really explain what you want to get done. Be as descriptive as possible and try to have your vision bolstered by diagrams, flow charts and organization charts where and when needed. I also urge you to use collaborative tools designed for the management of software development.
#2
Treat Your Outsourcing Team As An Employee Or Partner...Not A Vendor
Might seem obvious but for some people it is not as easy. Treat your offshore staff as employees or partners in your venture. Stay in constant communication, (at least once a day), ask what is new and ask for progress reports. Also..make it a point o use video conferencing to have face to face time with the main people in your team (Project Manager or Lead Developer)....over time this will greatly reduce communication barriers.
#3
Have clear goals and milestones goals
Don't fall into the trap of continuing development thinking that the final product will be just fine. Make it a point to have clear milestones and performance goals established. Track the progress the team is reporting in the daily reports versus the timeline in the milestones. (sprints). If there are delays get to the bottom of it. Making your team feel accountable will go a long way to ensure that you finish on time and budget.
#4
Be Realistic in your expectations
There is nothing worse in an outsourcing relationship than unrealistic expectations. In particular when the relationship is new it is important to set goals which can be met (assuming that the team does its job). Going back to # 2; unrealistic expectations can be very demotivating to you and your team. You owe it to yourself and your new team to offer a fair chance to succeed. Unrealistic expectations are an easy way to make sure that you feel your outsourcing venture it is a failure.
#5
Pick a good outsourcing partner
I put this purposely last. The fact of the matter is that all of the above is irrelevant if you happen to end up with a body shop which is simply incapable working in a cooperative environment. These vendors will have the lowest price (which makes them attractive) but you will end up in a situation where quality of the work and a strong client orientated collaborative approach is not a goal.
I would like to mention that a good BPO partner will have a structure in place which takes some of the responsibility mentioned in points 1, 2 and 3 away from you and automates the suggested processes. This will greatly help the process.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)