Does Legal Process Outsourcing Work ?..You Bet It Does!

Legal Process Outsourcing or LPO is one of those services which are more difficult to evaluate in its performance than other more conventional BPO services.

Unlike those more conventional services which often times have easy to validate Key Performance Indicators (completed processes, error rates, accuracy rates and so on) LPO is a bit more tricky to asses.

Depending upon which tasks is being outsourced the validation of Key Performance Indicators is usually not an obvious solution. After all, discovery documents being improperly prepared or reviewed will often times only show up months later as a potential problem.

As such LPO has been existing in a bit of a vacuum..law firms use it more and more but no one really knows much about whether it really works.

The fact that law firms are usually privately owned makes it even more difficult to asses if LPO is one of the methods employed to successfully reduce their expense ratio. Transparency is just not a high priority when it comes to dealing with attorneys.

An interesting insight into the validity of LPO was provided through a survey conducted by Corbin Partners and Taran Virtual Associates. In the survey about 250 Canadian law firms and attorneys were asked if they were using LPO and if so, what their  satisfaction rating was with the services provided.

The survey provides a rather interesting viewpoint of the Canadian legal industry. It established that
40 % of respondents said they use LPO currently.

Out of the 40 % who use the service the breakdown of services utilized was (multiple selections were possible):

  • 51 % use the service for legal consultations  and opinions
  • 37 % use it for agency services
  • 37 % use it for trial and appellate work
  • 36 % use the service for legal research
  • 28 % use it for clerk and paralegal support
  • 24 % use it for document review and discovery
The most important takeaway from the survey though was the level of overall satisfaction. Of those who were currently using LPO:

45 % reported that they were very satisfied with the service
41 % reported that they were somewhat satisfied
9 % reported they were neither satisfied or dissatisfied 
5 % reported that they were somewhat (3%)  or very dissatisfied (2%) with the service

Only 5 % of the respondents reported dissatisfaction with the service. This makes it clear that LPO is here to stay.

Considering that 60 % of the respondents in the survey did currently not use the service it seems that the industry as a whole has some room to grow.

If you consider that the providers of LPO services will continue to perfect their processes it seems plausible that they will also work themselves deeper into the law firms over time.

A provider might start out with just discovery as the outsourced process but there should be a good chance that over time more and more functions will be turned over to the LPO provider.

Judging by the results of the survey LPO is here to stay and business should be good for the industry in the years to come.











How You Can Make Sure That Your Arbitration Clause Is Air Tight When Dealing With An Overseas Outsourcing Partner

No one wants to go to court. This is even more true when your potential adversary is residing in a jurisdiction where the ability to enforce US laws is limited at best. (Mexico, China and India will for the most part not enforce US judgments)

It therefor has become the norm within the outsourcing world that  most contracts are using arbitration clauses to safeguard the legal interest of the parties.

Commercial Arbitration Firms like JAMS offer an alternative dispute resolution process which is faster and also cheaper than what is available through the courts. An added benefit might be that because of the nature of arbitration (private resolution) there is a significantly greater degree of confidentiality.


The big advantage arbitration does have is that  countries like China, Mexico and India have  signed the New York Convention for the Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards, thus enabling the collection of judgements even in those countries which would not enforce a judgement obtained at a US court. 

Another significant advantage utilizing the arbitration route is less cost and less time consuming, both of which constitute a  significant advantages as compared to litigate in front of a US court.

There are of course pitfalls to consider when executing an arbitration clause. The wording of the clause has to be as such that it will withstand legal scrutiny in case a party wants to evade their arbitration responsibility.

At the very least the following key points should be incorporated into the arbitration clause:


  • A provision stating that "all disputes arising under or in connection with the agreement shall be resolved" by the rules of a particular international arbitration organization
  • A clear location of arbitration
  • The number of arbitrators involved (typically one or three)
  • The language in which the arbitration process will occur
  • An agreement that any awards issued by the arbitrators "may be enforced in any court of competent jurisdiction"
Obviously a competent attorney should review any contract to make sure that the legal language used is up to par.  

Looking out for the proper arbitration language will go a long way that in a situation where an outsourcing relationship has gone sour. No one ever wants to go to court and in a situation where some kind of dispute resolution is considered arbitration is a much better bet.

   








Robotic Process Automation (RPA) Is Coming...Here Are Some Estimates As To How Much Cheaper It will Be

Robotic Process Automation is coming hard and fast. One of the industry which has the most to lose is the BPO industry.

At its most basic level the Robots will take over repetitive mundane tasks which are currently done through a help desk or are happening on a fixed easy to automate schedule. Payroll processing, password recovery, service alerts and updates are some of the tasks which can easily be allocated towards a Robot.

What has made the BPO industry successful is the concept of labor arbitrage. A task which costs X domestically can be performed at a fraction of X with a BPO provider who employs at its core a labor arbitrage model to provide value to its customers.

Robots will challenge that model rather dramatically. Not only will the Robot lead to lower fees...it can also conceivably be deployed by the onshore customer, cutting out the BPO provider altogether.

The simple fact is that the resources a customer allocates towards the management and supervision of a BPO relationship might equal the resources needed to maintain an In-House robot...thus eliminating the BPO provider completely.

In my opinion the cost reduction associated with a Robotic Process Automation will lead to reductions in BPO fees of 75 % or more (depending upon the licensing model of the Robotic technology).

I consider this number even conservative. Since Quality Control and Capacity Utilization will be a Non-Issue in a Robotic Process Automation environment BPO providers will loose their pricing advantage. Not only can they not claim any more that their BPO services are "better"..the actual Robot can also  be duplicated by other vendors...thus creating an opportunity for customers to exert real pricing pressure.

The article below makes a few good points as to RPA. I disagree somewhat with their anticipated reduction in fees...in my opinion the reduction for customers should be significantly bigger that what the article seems to suggest.

Article: Robotic Process Automation, Economics of it

Never the less though..it is a great article which makes quite a few good points.














The "How To Bible" for a Non Tech Person How To Supervise Outsourced Software Development

The decision to outsource a new application development often times seems like a rather daunting tasks for a business executive who has never supervised outsourced application development.

The simple truth is that not all companies have the In House tech staff who is experienced in organizing and supervising outsourced software development.

Fortunately the proper way to be successful when outsourcing software development is really not that complicated. Below is a 6 step list which, when followed, should ensure that your outsourced software development will no go off the rail.

Please note that the steps below are only applicable once you have selected the right outsourcing provider. Obviously, if your selected outsourcing partner does not deliver on the technology it can get rather tricky.


Step 1:  Requirements Management and Audit
You start with the most important item first. A detailed analysis of the requirements is key. Each capability of what the software needs to do has to be properly documented. Additionally you have to assign the proper permissions, (edit, read, modify, delete and so on) to each user level which is authorized to access the data relevant to that function and or feature. There is a good chance that your Outsourcing Provider will have a Requirement Manager on staff who will guide you through the process. If not...assign a member of your team that responsibility. Once you have the requirements down schedule meetings with the Lead Developer or Team Leader and run through all the requirements to clarify any misconceptions which might arise. A well thought out requirement list will ensure that your application has all the features you need while avoiding excess development time which might arise due to changes and/or additions which become otherwise necessary.

Step 2: Testing Tools
Once the outsourced software development team starts working testing of what is produced becomes the most important task. The Quality Assurance needs to stay on top of the development process to make sure that the development is correctly aligned with the requirements. Gantt and/or waterfall charts should be used to structure the development process into easy to follow steps. (the sprints). Your outsourcing partner will have a dedicated QA team (Quality Assurance). However, you or the person tasked with supervising the development will need to make sure that testing is done in accordance with the progress the developers make. It goes without saying, testing should never be done on the live app...a dedicated testing environment is something your outsourcing partner should have set up for the entire development process.

Step 3: Timelines
Besides the quality of the product timeliness of the development effort should be your second most important priority. You want your development effort to stay on track. As such it is vital that prior to development the estimated time and allocation of resources is done. Reputable outsourcers will provide detailed estimates as to how long the development of certain milestones (broken into sprints) will take. By tracking actual hours spent versus the estimate you will be able to easily ascertain  if the project is on schedule. Reputable software development firms will have that process down by using specific project management software which makes them accountable based upon the  hours pent versus a prior estimate.

Step 4: Consistent Feedback
It goes without saying...your outsourcing partner needs to know what you think. You need to regularly review how the software works and test it. Based upon your testing you need to provide feedback as to what features are to be amended and changed. It is much easier to change requirements early on while the particular feature is still under development. If you do not have the time to engage in regular testing assign the task to someone else and make them responsible to provide the needed feedback.

Step 5: Solicit Advise From Your Outsourcing Partner
You might have very specific ideas as to what the software needs to do. However, often times the outsourcing provider might have some very valuable ideas as to how to build a "better mousetrap". Technology moves at rapid speeds and there is a pretty good chance that your outsourcing provider has a good idea of how to improve upon desired functionality without adding much to the development effort. By cooperating and soliciting feedback throughout the process  you will end up with a better product; without necessarily making it more expensive.

Step 6: Test After It Is All Done
There is nothing more disruptive then having a new software release out with your customers and/or staff and then realizing that there is a problem. It is never good to roll back a software release. The problem might be with the functionality or feature or with platform compatibility. Therefor you will need to make sure that once you have the final product ready to go that it is performing as required and that it works on the platforms your business needs to support. (various browsers and operating systems, desktops, tablets and phones). The above might seem trivial...but I have personally encountered software releases where quite a few remote team members of a customer were still working on XP and Vista  even though the requirements were to be compatible with Windows 7 and up. Proper beta testing  can avoid disruption in business processes prior to making the software operational.


Supervising outsourced software development is easier than people often times think. By following the steps outlined above there is a pretty good chance that your project will go off without a hitch.













The Changing Role Of The CIO and How Outsourcing Is The Enabler

It is pretty obvious to winning organizations  that the role of technology within a business has been changing dramatically over the past 15 years.

In the old days technology was used to manage a business...to some degree or another. Every company was using technology which often times was similar in its application and features  vis a vis the customer. Technology was really not a deciding factor in the success of a business.

The success of a Kmart versus a Sears was  not dependent upon which company had the better online offering, nor did they have to worry about the emergence of other players competing for their customers.

Obviously, this situation has changed dramatically for a lot of older and established corporations.

In this day and age technology is used to enable customers to access a corporations goods and services in an easier and more convenient way (who has the better online presence). Additional services never been seen before have developed  challenging brick and mortar industries (Uber, Lyft, Airbnb).

In combination all of the above have led to a change in objectives for the CIO.

In the old days the CIO was expected to keep the technology running  so that the business processes making the business successful kept on running smoothly.

Nowadays he or she is tasked to create value (innovate) while at the same time reducing costs. Of course, innovate is nothing else than the task to create additional revenues or, at  the very least reduce the expense versus revenue spread. (gross margin).

For a lot of corporations the go to solution in their never ending quest to out-innovate their peers is outsourcing Business Processes. The idea is that a high level BPO provider will not only deliver meaningful cost cuts...it is also expected that the technical know how and delivered solution improves upon the Key Performance Indicators the business uses to benchmark its operational success.

The goal to cut costs is nothing new for any business. What is new though is that business use outsourcing to get ready for Web 3.0 or just position themselves better within the Web 2.0 environment. The digitization of the business is no longer something which is done only internally...it is increasingly entrusted to third party vendors.

The graph below shows the results of a Deloitte Study regarding the motivation of CIO's to use outsourcing.

What does stand out is that besides cost cutting the primary benefit/innovation attributed to the outsourced process are  :

  • Solving Capacity Issues (45 %)
  • Creating global scalability (29%)
  • Providing access to intellectual capital (28%)

Perhaps the most interesting finding is that in 28 % of the cases the  respondent cited the access to intellectual capital as the reason to embark on the process. Barely 15 years ago no organization would have considered an outsourcing relationship as a suitable solution to beef up on intellectual capital. 

At the end of the day it remains to be seen is this trend continues. Never the less though it is becoming clear that outsourcing has come a long way. 







Top 10 Users of H1-B Are All Outsourcing Companies

It should not be a surprise, but I have to admit that the extent to which some companies rely on H1-B visas to build up their US workforce was a bit surprising.  Perhaps more surprising is that the Top 10 beneficiaries of H1-B visas are all in the business of offering outsourcing services.

The debate of whether H1-B visas are offering  a backdoor for corporations to lower their salary base without having a legitimate need to procure the talent overseas has been raging for a long time.


The  Economic Policy Institute (author of the graph shown above)   is undoubtedly critical of the practice.

 One needs to remember though that  a legitimate need is often times the driver behind the H1-B imports. The US does have a shortage of IT personnel and without the H1-B program and the accumulated import of foreign workers which has happened since the inception of the program certain industries in this country would not be in the "fighting form" they are in right now.

The contribution  H1-B workers have been making for countless corporations are significant and a huge net positive.

Never the less though, the numbers speak for themselves and certainly made me make a double take.