Showing posts with label Work Process. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Work Process. Show all posts

Which Is Better...An Actively Managed Or Passively Managed Outsourcing/BPO/KPO Relationship?

When setting up an outsourcing relationship one of the decision which has to be made (and arguably perhaps the most important one) is how to  manage the outsourcing relationship.

A lot of companies (in particular smaller and midsize)  are really not considering the different approaches as to how to manage and utilize the relationship. 

There are two distinct approaches to managing an outsourcing relationship. One approach is to utilize the Passively Managed Approach...the other one is the Actively Managed Approach.

There are advantages and disadvantages to both. 

The characteristics of the different approaches can best be described as follows:

Passively Managed Relationship (PMR):

The approach is characterized by having a defined (non dynamic) responsibility the outsourcing provider is tasked with. It is chosen because the client wishes to utilize the expertise and competency of the outsourcing provider in a defined field. The client utilizes the organizational knowledge available. 

The scope of the relationship is contractually defined  and as such Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) can be set.  By using easily quantifiable KPIs benchmarking and evaluation is easily achievable.    

Actively Managed Relationship (AMR):

The responsibilities using the AMR approach are rather loosely defined. Instead of hiring the outsourcing provider to benefit from their organizational knowledge (expertise in certain processes) the client hires workers with certain qualifications. 

These workers  are then tasked dynamically to satisfy the needs of the clients. The tasks assigned will change throughout the duration of the contract as per the client instructions. Because the relationship has not been clearly defined during the contract stage KPIs are most often not easily identifiable. 


Which Model To Choose:

When reviewing the two different approaches to manage the relationship it is helpful to identify what drives the need for the AMR versus the PMR. 

The PMR has been the favorite of corporations for the longest time. Not a lot of companies wanted to utilize the AMR model. Corporations like the PMR model because it makes everyone accountable. KPIs are properly defined and expectations can be measured against the KPIs. 

However..this has been changing over the past few years. 
The AMR model has been gaining in popularity.

The driver behind an increased adoption of the AMR model has been the increased pace of technology changes forced upon corporations. Simply put....the need to adapt to changing technology trends has rendered the PMR model often times useless for a lot of corporations. 

The emergence of the cloud and the digital marketplace have greatly increased the pace at which technology changes have to happen...and a PMR is often times not capable to keep up with the change in requirements.

The need to evolve is what has been forcing companies to adopt the AMR model. 
Of course..there are also challenges which come with it.

I believe there are two distinct disadvantage  utilizing the AMR model.

First of all the lack of KPIs makes it not as easy to evaluate if the relationship is working well. Expectations cannot be measured against results as in the PMR model.

Secondly, there is a need for greater management involvement by the client. In order to make the outsourcing relationship work using the AMR model the client has to integrate itself more closely into the day to day operations of the outsourcing provider. As the name suggests...Actively Managed Relationship (AMR)   truly means more active involvement.

At the end of the day it comes down to what the client(the corporation) needs. If the client believes there is real need to be dynamic and respond to changing technology trends then the AMR model is the way to go.

The need to stay involved from the client side and the relative lack of KPIs is a small price to pay if the results are delivered. 

On the other hand..if all what the client needs is the expertise an outsourcing provider can deliver pertaining to a defined area of responsibility...then the PMR approach is the way to go.  It certainly is easier to manage from the clients perspective.













Why Accountability Is Key To A Successful Outsourcing Relationship....

The worst situation which can potentially arise when outsourcing any type of business process is when the communication link  between the onshore client and the offshore outsourcing  provider gets broken.

I always like to say  before the business relationship went sour the communication went dead.

The simple truth of the matter is that not every onshore employee is excited to work with a company based in India, Philippines or Eastern Europe (or some other country which is hardly known to onshore staff),

That hesitation sometimes can lead to a lack of communication which then can create a viscous  cycle. Because of the lack of feedback from the client the quality of the work product starts to slip. The degradation in quality leads to even further resentment by onshore staff.

Needless to say, problems like the above combined with  time and cultural differences as well as  a language problem have crushed more than a few outsourcing deals.

At the end Senior Management looks at the entire outsourcing relationship and wonders why it does not seem to be working as well as they think it should.

In order to avoid a scenario where the entire outsourcing relationship falls apart it makes sense to implement the 7  rules and guidelines shown below:



  1. Early in the process designate at least one person, better a team of people who will be in charge of managing the day to day operation of your outsourcing relationship. Include them in the meetings as early in the process as possible. The goal is to familiarize them with the inner workings of the deal as well as giving your outsourcing provider early and easy access to the Relationship Managers.   
  2. Senior Management has to clearly define Key Performance Indicators (KPI'S) which it wants to meet. The KPIs  have to be clearly laid out in such a way that both, onshore local relationship management and offshore provider are made jointly responsible for reaching them. They have to be joint at the hip....one parties failure will be deemed the other parties failure as well. 
  3. Insist on daily meetings between key personnel..ideally twice a day. Use a video conferencing tool (skype is fine too). It might seem trivial but the use of video will greatly enhance familiarity between key personnel and thus will increase productivity. 
  4. Insist on reports. Develop a report structure which is being fed to Senior Management at predetermined intervals. (daily, weekly). The reports you receive should be based upon the prior discussed KPI's. Also...make clear that both teams, onshore and offshore will be jointly held responsible for failure. 
  5. Have regular meetings with both teams (joint meetings). Once again, video conferencing is preferred. Address any issues you might have in reaching KPIs. Solicit suggestions to improve performance.
  6. Have individual meetings with each team (the onshore and the offshore team, video once again). Get them to spill the beans if there is any sand in the relationship. Use the information to fine tune instructions during the next joint meeting. 
  7. Set realistic expectations. For the teams as well as for the company. It is well established that outsourcing has an initial productivity gap versus the comparable onshore solution. That productivity gap will close over time. Your KPIs will be your measuring stick. 


The over reaching goal is to foster a culture of accountability. Making the onshore staff responsible at an early stage and creating a joint responsibility for the KPI's will produce better results.

If the above is properly implemented the onshore staff will not be able to just point fingers to the offshore provider and issue blame.

By instituting this level of accountability your new outsourcing relationship should be off to a good start.