Which Is Better...An Actively Managed Or Passively Managed Outsourcing/BPO/KPO Relationship?

When setting up an outsourcing relationship one of the decision which has to be made (and arguably perhaps the most important one) is how to  manage the outsourcing relationship.

A lot of companies (in particular smaller and midsize)  are really not considering the different approaches as to how to manage and utilize the relationship. 

There are two distinct approaches to managing an outsourcing relationship. One approach is to utilize the Passively Managed Approach...the other one is the Actively Managed Approach.

There are advantages and disadvantages to both. 

The characteristics of the different approaches can best be described as follows:

Passively Managed Relationship (PMR):

The approach is characterized by having a defined (non dynamic) responsibility the outsourcing provider is tasked with. It is chosen because the client wishes to utilize the expertise and competency of the outsourcing provider in a defined field. The client utilizes the organizational knowledge available. 

The scope of the relationship is contractually defined  and as such Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) can be set.  By using easily quantifiable KPIs benchmarking and evaluation is easily achievable.    

Actively Managed Relationship (AMR):

The responsibilities using the AMR approach are rather loosely defined. Instead of hiring the outsourcing provider to benefit from their organizational knowledge (expertise in certain processes) the client hires workers with certain qualifications. 

These workers  are then tasked dynamically to satisfy the needs of the clients. The tasks assigned will change throughout the duration of the contract as per the client instructions. Because the relationship has not been clearly defined during the contract stage KPIs are most often not easily identifiable. 


Which Model To Choose:

When reviewing the two different approaches to manage the relationship it is helpful to identify what drives the need for the AMR versus the PMR. 

The PMR has been the favorite of corporations for the longest time. Not a lot of companies wanted to utilize the AMR model. Corporations like the PMR model because it makes everyone accountable. KPIs are properly defined and expectations can be measured against the KPIs. 

However..this has been changing over the past few years. 
The AMR model has been gaining in popularity.

The driver behind an increased adoption of the AMR model has been the increased pace of technology changes forced upon corporations. Simply put....the need to adapt to changing technology trends has rendered the PMR model often times useless for a lot of corporations. 

The emergence of the cloud and the digital marketplace have greatly increased the pace at which technology changes have to happen...and a PMR is often times not capable to keep up with the change in requirements.

The need to evolve is what has been forcing companies to adopt the AMR model. 
Of course..there are also challenges which come with it.

I believe there are two distinct disadvantage  utilizing the AMR model.

First of all the lack of KPIs makes it not as easy to evaluate if the relationship is working well. Expectations cannot be measured against results as in the PMR model.

Secondly, there is a need for greater management involvement by the client. In order to make the outsourcing relationship work using the AMR model the client has to integrate itself more closely into the day to day operations of the outsourcing provider. As the name suggests...Actively Managed Relationship (AMR)   truly means more active involvement.

At the end of the day it comes down to what the client(the corporation) needs. If the client believes there is real need to be dynamic and respond to changing technology trends then the AMR model is the way to go.

The need to stay involved from the client side and the relative lack of KPIs is a small price to pay if the results are delivered. 

On the other hand..if all what the client needs is the expertise an outsourcing provider can deliver pertaining to a defined area of responsibility...then the PMR approach is the way to go.  It certainly is easier to manage from the clients perspective.













Is The H1-B Visa Festival Finally Going To End ?

H1-B Visas are a tricky subject. They are given out in a limited number per year (65,000 is the cap for 2017) and are sought by corporations in order to bring in what is considered specialized labor which cannot be found locally.

There are several restrictions associated with the application process....mostly designed to prevent the H1-B visa worker form taking over the jobs of US workers.

The problem is that there have been numerous cases where workers have been exchanged against a (presumably) lower paid worker who was brought in with a H1-B visa.

The practice has been always been viewed with disdain but it looks like there are a few things happening which might limit the appeal of H1-B visas in the future...or at least it won't be that easy anymore to exchange workers on a 1 to 1 basis.

One meaningful change to the law which is in the works is that workers will be able to contest their firing if they believe they are being laid off and being exchanged with a H1-B visa employee.

This is what seems to have happened at Abbott Labs in April 2016.  Apparently 150 tech employees were let go  and on the way out were asked to hand over their security credentials to newly incoming H1-B workers.

Of course every employee had to sign a Non Disclosure/Disparaging Agreement in exchange for severance....so details are hard to come by.

For more details read: Abbott labs lets 150 people go

One employed though did not sign the agreement and is speaking up. Consequently it now looks like some politicians  have picked up on the issue and are going to strengthen regulatory oversight.

Given the current political climate this should hardly come as a surprise.

Given the abuse in the H1-B program additional regulation might be a really good thing.

Regulations of course might not do the trick if the abuse is fraudulent.
Fraudulent abuse like the one initiated by Infosys and fined in 2013  is obviously much more serious than misuse and might deserve more scrutiny.

For More information read: Infosys pays record 34 Mio fine for immigration fraud

At the end of the day it will require a combination of better regulations and enforcement of existing laws to plug the hole through which the system has been abused. Corporations need access to talent and hopefully revisions to the law will not change that. At the same time US workers should also not be shortchanged...so let's hope that lawmakers will strike the right balance.



How A Two Speed IT Structure Can Give Any Company The Edge...

It is a concept which has not gone mainstream yet but it has been gathering a following now for a few years.

I am talking about the concept of having a Slow Speed IT lane and a High Speed IT lane within the same organization.

Over the past years a lot of companies have embarked upon the digital transformation the market place (their customers) have demanded.

Digital transformation means a lot of different things to different people but most commonly the following IT challenges are understood to be part of the digital transformation package:


  • Online Systems (Web Applications)
  • Mobile Apps
  • Social Media 
The challenge is of course that things happen much faster on the web (the digital marketplace) than a lot of IT organizations are used to operate at. An IT department which has been supporting the legacy component of an organizations IT infrastructure does usually not need to move very fast. 

Legacy systems are ordinarily updated rather infrequently...so there is often times the mindset that being slow or deliberate is not a bad thing. There are still plenty of organizations which run enterprise software off an AS/400 and/or use Windows Vista.  

The issue of course is that this mindset is producing  a competitive disadvantage in the digital marketplace. 

Companies are falling behind in their Key Performance Indicators vis a vis their more aggressive, digitally savvy  peers. 

CIO's and Decision makers do realize that a huge part of addressing the shortcomings is to foster a culture which is more geared towards the Digital Marketplace. 

Needless to say...sometimes this is easier said than done.

Often times the very same decision makers which are tasked with spearheading the transformation are part of the culture where slow and deliberate is good.

So..the question of how to get ahead of the curve and transform into the Digital Marketplace deserves to be looked at. 

Perhaps the easiest and most practical solution is to outsource the Digital Transformation to outsourcing companies who have a lot of experience in that area while maintaining the existing In House IT infrastructure.

The effect is what is being called a Two Tier IT infrastructure. One lane is High Speed (Digital Transformation and Strategies) and the other lane, Slow Speed lane, deals with  Core Legacy and Maintenance. 

There are a few advantages operating a two tier IT infrastructure. Presumably the outsourcing provider is up to date on the latest technologies and even more important,  stays up to date...thus ensuring that the organization is able to outperform its competitors. 

The core IT team remains relatively unaffected and can concentrate on the issues they have proven to  be good at. 

In combination the two Speed Lanes can offer a successful blueprint how an organization can become more agile while maintaining the continuity needed to safeguard existing business processes.



 


Jamaica Clearly Seems To Be The Best Horse In The Barn For Xerox.....

I had written about the Jamaican BPO sector before. It is clearly a niche market with only 17,000 employees as of right now (albeit it is growing at a 20 % plus rate) but it has some distinct advantages over the more traditional outsourcing countries.

It has some pretty good universities which produces a fair amount of talent, it is in the same time zone as the US (same time zone as Chicago) , salary levels are about 70 % below US salary levels and the official language is English.

Perhaps the single biggest advantage is the typical very "sunny disposition" of the average Jamaican...one will be hard pressed to find a Jamaican who is openly in a bad mood.

No company has placed a bigger bet onto the Jamaican BPO sector than Xerox. The total BPO workforce of Xerox in Jamaica is about 7000 right now...giving Xerox about 18 % market share in an industry which is usually much more fragmented.

The 7000 headcount of Xerox makes them the biggest employer in Jamaica (after the government of course).

Most interestingly, Xerox investment into Jamaica seems to be paying off for them. Internal Key Performance Indicators (KPI's) are hard to come by but a recent article (see here)  disclosed that the Jamaican BPO office has a 98.5 % satisfaction rating with its healthcare clients...which should make them one of the highest rated office within Xerox.

One reason given why the offices is doing so well is low turnover. The Jamaican office has apparently the lowest turnover of all Xerox locations worldwide. In an industry which is characterized by high attrition rates that feat is obviously remarkable and undoubtedly leads to higher customer satisfaction.

Jamaica obviously lacks the infrastructure and population to be attractive to the major players in the BPO industry. The headcount required to make a dent in their operation for the  biggest BPO players cannot be reasonably made available in Jamaica.

The lesson learned from the Xerox experience though is that on a more individual level companies looking for a good alternative to set up their BPO operation Jamaica might be a good idea.











Who Is Winning The Outsourcing Cloud Wars ?....

Undoubtedly the rise of the cloud over the past few years has created tremendous dislocations within the IT sector. Outsourcing hardware and infrastructure needs started with moving equipment into data centers, took on a life of its won and ended with the rise of companies who had never been in the "hardware business" before.

Players like Amazon (AWS) and Google (GCP) who were never a factor as a provider of the technical backbone for corporations are now firmly entrenched in a lot of organizations. Microsoft, who was always present through their software solutions is now battling it out with everyone else as a cloud provider (Azure).

Then there are the established players who have built their own cloud to support their operations.

Perhaps no company has been more aggressive in developing its cloud than Salesforce. Their entire business has been built to be cloud centric from the start...and one can argue that the cloud made their business possible.

For CEO's and CIO's at companies operating their own cloud the question of whether one of the big 3 players in the field (AWS, AZURE , GCP) might do a better job than their own Internal Data Centers always gets deliberated.

The cost / benefit analysis is rather difficult in many situations. Not only does the company stand to loose certain functionality, it also has to consider the reputational effect when a technology company operating its own cloud effectively concedes defeat and moves its cloud to one of the big 3.

Yet, this is exactly what happened at Salesforce. Salesforce has chosen Amazon's AWS to power most of their core services. (Sales Cloud, Service Cloud, App Cloud, Community Cloud , Analytics Cloud)

It is a rather stunning announcement.  Salesforce who has been on the forefront of running perhaps the single most successful cloud business there is decided to move a significant portion of its cloud to a company which was barely  in the business of operating a cloud service 10 years ago. (AWS was started in 2006)

Undoubtedly this is an event which will ring the bells at a lot of corporations who operate their won cloud. If the preeminent cloud centric business decides to outsource their cloud to AWS - what justification can be found by other companies to continue operating their own cloud ?

Salesforce might have been early ..but it just rang the exit bell for pretty much every company to close up their own cloud.


















Strange News...Indian Outsourcing Company PLans To Hire 25,000 Workers

An Indian Outsourcing / BPO company has announced that it intends to hire 25,000 workers. The number is obviously staggering on a lot of levels and reading the newspaper article one has to wonder if the company will ever manage to do so.

Never the less..the number is certainly eye catching..and that might very well be part of the reason why it is publicized. Makes for some good PR.

Horizon Outsourcing Solutions is an Indian based provider of BPO solutions and currently has a headcount of "only" 3000. As such it is looking to grow its employee count by a heft 900 % in the next two years.

The hires are apparently semi skilled/non skilled..as per the company.  As such the focus will be on providing telephone and back office related BPO services.

It speaks to the depth of the Indian job market that a number likes this can be thrown out without being ridiculed. It will be interesting to watch if Horizon can pull it off. If so..it would certainly be a testament to some serious management skills.

Full article with the release can be found here:  Indian Company Wants To Increase Headcount By 900 %