Traditional BPO providers have had a challenging business environment globally. EMEA has been down a solid double digits last year (-18 %) and APAC was down a more moderate single digit number. (-6.3%).
The BPO industry has always been rather fragmented. One problem has always been how to capture the correct data to come up with estimated revenue numbers for the industry as a whole. Market intelligence firms are usually looking at Annual Contract values above 5 Million (some firms will include lower ACV's of 3 Million US-$).
As such the decline in Annual Revenue numbers is rather "top heavy"...it is geared towards bigger contract values.
What is not captured in annual revenue numbers is the shift away from traditional BPO providers to a more distributed workforce model.
A new breed of providers has emerged which cater specifically to organizations who have demand spikes for services followed by a significant decline.
In the past conventional BPO providers were tasked to absorb those demand surges and had to staff accordingly. Not any longer.
There are now specialized providers who offer "On Demand" (aka Access Contractors) employees to handle those demand spikes. The model is highly attractive to any sales heavy organization (etailers) which has to absorb strong seasonal changes in sales volume. (either promotional or seasonal driven)
The distributed workforce model has always been plagued by a rather high error rate. But that has been changing. Tasks have been further reduced into missions. A mission specific employee is tasked with such a small subset or responsibilities that training and subsequent error rate are both minimal.
Making an employee mission specific instead of a more general trained employee in a BPO environment has allowed the distributed workforce model to gain rapid speed.
There are companies in India which have created significant workforce's of on demand workers which can be marshaled into action within a few minutes. (the biggest providers are in the 1000's of workers or "Access Contractors").
Access Contractors claim that there error rate is about even to the error rate of conventional BPO providers.
The lure of using an Access Contractor is in the associated savings. Savings can be as high as 70 % (!) vis a vis a conventional BPO provider.
Given the realized savings it is easy to foresee continued revenue drain for the established BPO providers. It is one more thing to worry about, besides the emergence of cloud services and AI.
A collection of comments,newsworthy articles and posts dealing with outsourcing and BPO services by Steve Benger
- Home
- Which Are Better..Indian or Philippines Call Centers ?
- Why Your Business Will Benefit From Outsourcing
- Is Your Web Presence Up To Par ?
- How IBM's Watson Might Kill The Call Center Industry
- How To Test Your Outsourced Software Development
- Guerrilla CEO…How To Adapt When Needed
- Think Your Don't Need a Business Mobile App? Think Again!
Strange News - Phone Fraud puts Indian BPO providers on the defensive
Most people have been getting unsolicited calls from (mostly) Indian call centers. Sometimes the calls are simply a solicitation for a product...sometimes the reason for the call is much more sinister.
The Federal Trade Commission has received about 400,00 calls last year regarding what it deems "imposter scams" where the caller claims to be from law enforcement or even the IRS...with the motive to extort money.
In almost every case the caller has an Indian accent (or an accent which is deemed Indian). The problem which has been arising for the BPO industry is that distrust is brewing between consumers and operators of BPO companies because of it.
The consumer who calls his bank, or even worse, gets called by his bank and hears an Indian accent goes immediately on the defensive. Call center operations are not easy as it it is anyhow....and immediate distrust only makes it worse.
I can attest to the fact that the problem described above is very much front and center for executives planning to set up or relocate call center operations. The Indian Call Center industry is being tarnished...and it is becoming a factor for executives in charge of call center operations.
It is certainly not the main reason...but it a significant contributing factor why the Philippines are now the call center capital of the world.
The Federal Trade Commission has received about 400,00 calls last year regarding what it deems "imposter scams" where the caller claims to be from law enforcement or even the IRS...with the motive to extort money.
In almost every case the caller has an Indian accent (or an accent which is deemed Indian). The problem which has been arising for the BPO industry is that distrust is brewing between consumers and operators of BPO companies because of it.
The consumer who calls his bank, or even worse, gets called by his bank and hears an Indian accent goes immediately on the defensive. Call center operations are not easy as it it is anyhow....and immediate distrust only makes it worse.
I can attest to the fact that the problem described above is very much front and center for executives planning to set up or relocate call center operations. The Indian Call Center industry is being tarnished...and it is becoming a factor for executives in charge of call center operations.
It is certainly not the main reason...but it a significant contributing factor why the Philippines are now the call center capital of the world.
Should You Ever Visit Your Outsourcing Provider ?...Here Is What You Need To Consider
Big corporations with budgets of millions of dollars do it all the time..they visit their outsourcing provider...wherever they are located. Often times, and if the budget warrants it, they actually have a representative embedded with the outsourcing team..or at the very least have a local rep which looks after the relationship.
There are significant advantages to be realized...which is the reason why they do it.
The question I get asked sometimes if smaller scale projects are worth while to warrant a visit.
The short answer it "Sometimes"..and it depends.
There are a few things which go into the evaluation of whether or not a visit can make a difference.
That travel in almost every case leads to second or even third world countries and cities which require connecting flights. As such the decision to travel requires a more significant investment as it relates to time and money.
Below are some of the considerations a small business owner with a smaller project might want to consider to decide if the trip is worth his/her time.
Consideration 1
How long is the estimated time to completion of your project?
If the project is estimated to be completed within 6 weeks even a substantial overrun in time to completion might no be material to your business. If on the other hand estimated time to completion is 8 months..then a visit might make it more likely that the project will be on time.
Consideration 2
How expensive is your project...and are you responsible for cost overruns ?
This might be the cardinal question...if your project is only 5k...even a 40 % cost overrun amounts to only a 2 k difference. From a financial cost/benefit analysis it might make no sense to visit. If on the other hand the project is spec'ed out at 100 k...a 40 % increase would add an additional 40 k in expenses. Avoiding the additional expense might make it worth your time to go.
Consideration 3
When should you go and visit?
Assuming you have a time to completion numbered in months and a budget which, if there were a significant cost overrun, would make it economically feasible to plan a visit...you need to decide when you should visit. As a general rule..the earlier in the process you visit ..the better it will be. Your outsourced software development team will not get a lot of client visits. If you visit them you will l leave a definite mark on their thinking and they will be much more attentive to your needs for the remainder of the project.
Consideration 4
Will my visit make a difference as it relates to schedule and costs?
The short answer is unequivocally ...YES. It will. I can assure you that there is a pretty good chance that you might be the only client visiting the developers that year. If you buy them a meal, perhaps some drinks...you can be assured that there will be a lot of goodwill created. The Goodwill will translate into more diligence as to your project, saving you time and money.
Consideration 5
Do you have the time to go and spend at least a week with the team?
This consideration is something only you can decide. f you do have the time and like to travel to areas / cities which are usually not mainstream travel destinations...it might be a good idea.
Consideration 6
Does it make financial sense to travel?
I briefly touched on it in consideration 2. There is obviously little point in spending 5k on travel if the total project is 5k. As such there is a relationship between travel expenses and expected benefits. There is though another way of looking at it...and a lot of companies are utilizing that strategy. An alternative way to look at the projects costs is to include travel expenses upfront in your calculation. The combined project cost and travel expenses then make up the Total Project Costs. If the total Project Cost is sufficiently below what onshore development will cost you..then u have found the economic justification for travelling to your Outsourcing Provider.
At the end of the day the decision to travel is an individual one every business owner needs to decide for him/herself. I can attest to the fact that it will be beneficial.
Some people like to travel...and some do not. I have a client which always makes it a point to travel overseas to visit the software development team. For him it is a vacation in disguise, fully tax deductible.
That reasoning might not appeal to other business owners...but if you do have the time and like to explore different countries..this is certainly one way to make it tax deductible. And this is often times all the motivation a small business owners need.
Onshore, Nearshore or Offshore Software Development...here are some pros and cons
The day has come where you decide to outsource a software development project. There might be multiple reasons why but you now face the task of how to do it and get it done.
For someone who has never outsourced software development this might seem like a rather daunting task. After all...how do you get from idea to conclusion without having major hiccups on the way.
Business is all about proper execution of strategy...and you should treat your outsourcing approach the same way.
One of the first decisions has to be the geograpic which decision as to what type of outsourcing you want to pursue. There are 3 different categories of outsourcing available to you. Each comes with positives and negatives associated with their relative geographic area.
The table below provides some insight into some of the considerations you may want to entertain. The point of vies used is from a US perspective.
If you are based in Europe the geographic point of view provided below are obviously somewhat different.
At the end of the day it really comes down to what the company is prepared to pay...and the trade off the company is prepared to accept if it decides to pursue a lower cost provider.
There is little doubt that onshore development is the easiest one to manage. The downside is of course that the expense is by far the highest.
Conversely, true offshore development in Asia is usually the cheapest. A lot of corporations are comfortable with offshore development and are prepared to accept some of the difficulties working with a company on the other side of the clock.
For someone who has never outsourced software development this might seem like a rather daunting task. After all...how do you get from idea to conclusion without having major hiccups on the way.
Business is all about proper execution of strategy...and you should treat your outsourcing approach the same way.
One of the first decisions has to be the geograpic which decision as to what type of outsourcing you want to pursue. There are 3 different categories of outsourcing available to you. Each comes with positives and negatives associated with their relative geographic area.
The table below provides some insight into some of the considerations you may want to entertain. The point of vies used is from a US perspective.
If you are based in Europe the geographic point of view provided below are obviously somewhat different.
Definition
|
The Pros
|
The Cons
|
Onshore
Any development
partner which resides in your country is typically considered an outsourced
onshore development
|
No cultural
issues which can lead to misunderstandings
Same time zone,
cooperation during the day is a breeze
Easy to visit
the development partner, domestic flight, train or car trip
Consequently it
is easy to supervise
|
Onshore development is the most expensive. Reputable firms easily charge well above 150 US-$ for contract work
Onshore software
development firms frequently outsource their work to offshore providers. As a
client you might never learn about it. Hence you might overpay.
In some cases
onshore firms are very much tied into business networks which are closely
aligned with your business. Ideas or concepts you deem as confidential are
leaking to other companies in your space. This can happen through staff
attrition or related development work
|
Nearshore
A company which
resides in neighboring countries with a time zone difference of perhaps up to 4 or 5 hours is usually considered
Nearshore. Examples are South America, Canada, Jamaica
|
The provider is
removed but you still have between 4 to 6 hours of overlap in the time zones,
enabling you to efficiently cooperate throughout the day.
Pricing will be
significantly cheaper than onshore pricing.
There is a
certain cultural alignment. Developers in nations mentioned as nearshore
providers are used to the US way of thinking.
|
Nearshore development is not a radical solution. It is more expensive than offshore development as such a lot of the advantages are mitigated.
Nearshore
provider are not easy to reach. Travel times are frequently more than 8 or 10
hours and flight is the only option.
Nearshore
providers might have significant language barriers.
|
Offshore
Offshore
Development is usually associated with development done on other continents
with significant time zone differences. Examples are Asia and Europe
|
Offshore
providers are usually the cheapest by a wide margin.
Not unusual to
find development companies with big product portfolios and a lot of related
work experience.
Because true
offshore development companies tend to be bigger in size they usually have
defined processes to manage a relationship
|
Offshore Development centers reside on the other side of the clock. Time zone differences are usually 8 hours or more.
The command of
the English language is often times average. Only Project Managers and Senior
Developers speak good English.
Work hours
usually only overlap up to 4 hours.
|
At the end of the day it really comes down to what the company is prepared to pay...and the trade off the company is prepared to accept if it decides to pursue a lower cost provider.
There is little doubt that onshore development is the easiest one to manage. The downside is of course that the expense is by far the highest.
Conversely, true offshore development in Asia is usually the cheapest. A lot of corporations are comfortable with offshore development and are prepared to accept some of the difficulties working with a company on the other side of the clock.
Technical Support Outsourcing Continues To Grow...forecasted to grow at 6.53 % CAGR
There has been some anecdotal evidence that outsourcing is slowing down. Some of the major providers of BPO services have been making some noise that there is a deceleration in outsourcing contracts and revenues.
However, one of the top Market Intelligence Firms has released a report which counters that perceptions with some hard facts. They analysis shows the market has been growing and they forecast Compound Annual Growth Rates of 6.53 % for the period 2016 to 2020.
The full report, released by Market Study Report can be found here.
The report specifically covers a sub section of the BPO market. Technical Support is what it is all about in there. As such he report might not provide a full overview of the global BPO and KPO industry...but it makes clear that a significant chunk of it does not need to worry about a deceleration in revenues anytime soon.
If you would like to read the full report..there is one small problem.Market Study Reports are known to be somewhat expensive. This report is too..they are asking US-$ 2500.00. Fortunately they are open to negotiate a discounts and perhaps even a free sample report.
However, one of the top Market Intelligence Firms has released a report which counters that perceptions with some hard facts. They analysis shows the market has been growing and they forecast Compound Annual Growth Rates of 6.53 % for the period 2016 to 2020.
The full report, released by Market Study Report can be found here.
The report specifically covers a sub section of the BPO market. Technical Support is what it is all about in there. As such he report might not provide a full overview of the global BPO and KPO industry...but it makes clear that a significant chunk of it does not need to worry about a deceleration in revenues anytime soon.
If you would like to read the full report..there is one small problem.Market Study Reports are known to be somewhat expensive. This report is too..they are asking US-$ 2500.00. Fortunately they are open to negotiate a discounts and perhaps even a free sample report.
What' s To Come After Saas?...OaaS will be the next evolution for the Outsourcing/BPO industry
It is the story-line every business needs to follow in order to stay relevant.
It needs to improve and enhance it offering in order to stay competitive. If company "A" fails to do so it can be sure that company "B" will..thus outflanking and outperforming the business. Business is after all survival of the fittest.
The outsourcing industry is no different. Starting from very humble beginnings, operating mainly call centers, it quickly evolved into taking over administrative tasks. What were simple processes at first became more and more complex over the years. At one point entire business processes were outsourced..and the BPO industry was formally recognized.
The question and issue faced by many organizations is what is next?
The clients of BPO companies are always looking for another avenue to reduce costs further. The BPO companies, attempting to safeguard and increase existing revenue are trying to capture a bigger slice of the pie.
One avenue pursued by companies and their BPO partners is OaaS. (Operations as a Service).
Oaas in its simplest form is the outsourcing of entire departments. It is not limited to simple process but it is considered all encompassing. Often times significant business decisions are taken by the outsourcer, in accordance with the Master Service Agreement.
An example would be to have the entire procurement and related accounting and payment outsourced to a BPO provider. The BPO provider might have been involved in the process before. But rather than being limited to one or two processes which are parts of the puzzle it now is made responsible for all aspects of procurement.
Certain aspects of the business might have been operated in the form of SaaS. By taking over the entire operations area related to the SaaS solution the company effectively combines a SaaS solution with the operation of the solution into what is termed an OaaS solution.
A good way to think of it is to outsource a business division as opposed to outsourcing a department.
There is an obvious challenge to outsource entire business divisions. Any company deciding to go that route is effectively reorganizing the company..similar to a corporate reorganization.
The concept can be as limited or as all encompassing as a company wishes. As such the associated challenges can be managed in accordance with the scope of the project.
At the end of the day it really comes down to what the company believes should be its core competency.
If management beliefs that anything outside of its core line of business is open for an OaaS solution...then the process can be rather disruptive and transformative.
It might not be for every company but for those companies trying to reduce expenses even further and improving efficiency while doing so OaaS might be the only option to do so in a substantial manner.
It needs to improve and enhance it offering in order to stay competitive. If company "A" fails to do so it can be sure that company "B" will..thus outflanking and outperforming the business. Business is after all survival of the fittest.
The outsourcing industry is no different. Starting from very humble beginnings, operating mainly call centers, it quickly evolved into taking over administrative tasks. What were simple processes at first became more and more complex over the years. At one point entire business processes were outsourced..and the BPO industry was formally recognized.
The question and issue faced by many organizations is what is next?
The clients of BPO companies are always looking for another avenue to reduce costs further. The BPO companies, attempting to safeguard and increase existing revenue are trying to capture a bigger slice of the pie.
One avenue pursued by companies and their BPO partners is OaaS. (Operations as a Service).
Oaas in its simplest form is the outsourcing of entire departments. It is not limited to simple process but it is considered all encompassing. Often times significant business decisions are taken by the outsourcer, in accordance with the Master Service Agreement.
An example would be to have the entire procurement and related accounting and payment outsourced to a BPO provider. The BPO provider might have been involved in the process before. But rather than being limited to one or two processes which are parts of the puzzle it now is made responsible for all aspects of procurement.
Certain aspects of the business might have been operated in the form of SaaS. By taking over the entire operations area related to the SaaS solution the company effectively combines a SaaS solution with the operation of the solution into what is termed an OaaS solution.
A good way to think of it is to outsource a business division as opposed to outsourcing a department.
There is an obvious challenge to outsource entire business divisions. Any company deciding to go that route is effectively reorganizing the company..similar to a corporate reorganization.
The concept can be as limited or as all encompassing as a company wishes. As such the associated challenges can be managed in accordance with the scope of the project.
At the end of the day it really comes down to what the company believes should be its core competency.
If management beliefs that anything outside of its core line of business is open for an OaaS solution...then the process can be rather disruptive and transformative.
It might not be for every company but for those companies trying to reduce expenses even further and improving efficiency while doing so OaaS might be the only option to do so in a substantial manner.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



